The Rocky Mountain Collegian Wins Holland Award

2009_hollandThe Rocky Mountain Collegian, a student-run daily newspaper at Colorado State University, and its former editor-in-chief J. David McSwane, are winners of the fifth annual Betty Gage Holland Award for protecting the integrity of public dialogue on America’s college campuses.

The Holland Award is sponsored by the James M. Cox Jr. Institute for Newspaper Management Studies in the Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication at the University of Georgia. The annual award honors the late Betty Gage Holland, long-time friend of journalism education at the University of Georgia.

An award of $1,000 goes to student reporter McSwane and $1,000 to The Rocky Mountain Collegian as sponsor publication for their winning entry.

The Collegian and McSwane followed up on a tip from a campus police officer and an anonymous letter delivered to the paper that alleged misconduct by Colorado State’s police chief. Their investigation of the university’s top law enforcement official began in November 2008 and resulted in a two-month series, “Abuse of Power,” published in January through March 2009.

Just weeks after The Collegian began its investigation, the university announced that the police chief was on paid administrative leave pending a formal investigation. No reasons were given for the suspension or an inquiry by the Colorado Bureau of Investigation.

McSwane’s relentless interviews with current and former police officers and students revealed several cases of alleged misconduct, including sexual harassment. He also obtained audio recordings from the police chief’s classroom lectures that promoted illegal activities and questionable practices.

The Collegian and McSwane utilized the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and the Colorado Open Records Act to obtain copies of confidentiality agreements, salaries and a departing bonus when the police chief later resigned.

“Subsequent hiring of university officials and police personnel is now underscored by an intense effort from administration toward openness and reception of public inquiry,” wrote Holly Wolcott, The Collegian news adviser, in support of her publication’s entry. “Also, the school has restructured its Office of Equal Opportunity and Diversity, the office which received several complaints against the former chief but ultimately did nothing.”

The university later confirmed that former Police Chief Dexter Yarbrough’s investigation and subsequent resignation was the result of sexual harassment accusations.

Read the award-winning series here:Jan. 20, 2009 – Abuse of Power | Jan. 22, 2009 – Suspended Chief refutes allegations | Jan. 23, 2009 – Embattled Chief faces CBI probe | March 9, 2009 – CSUPD Chief Resigns

“The Cox Institute is proud – and Betty Holland would be proud – to honor the aggressive, public-service journalism of The Rocky Mountain Collegian and J. David McSwane,” said Conrad Fink, director of the Cox Institute and Grady College professor of journalism.”They served well their reader community, and that is what great journalism is all about.”

For more information on the Betty Gage Holland Award, contact Cecil Bentley at or (706) 542-4993. Holland Award winners and contest submission guidelines are available at

More Betty Gage Holland Award winners:

2015-2016 2014-2015 2013-2014 2012-2013 2011-2012

2010-2011 2009-2010 2008-2009 2007-2008 2006-2007